Why Posting on Social Media After a Car Accident Could Ruin Your Claim

In today’s digital world, sharing life’s moments on social media has become second nature. Whether it’s updating friends about an event, sharing a photo, or expressing feelings, social media platforms like Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, and TikTok have become integral to our daily routines. However, when you’ve been involved in a car accident and are pursuing a personal injury claim in Illinois, posting on social media can do more harm than good.

What you post online, even seemingly innocent updates, can be used against you by insurance companies and defense attorneys to weaken or deny your claim. This article will explain why posting on social media after a car accident could ruin your personal injury claim, the potential consequences of these posts, and provide real-life examples of how social media mistakes have impacted personal injury cases in Illinois.

The Role of Social Media in Personal Injury Cases

Insurance companies and defense attorneys are always looking for ways to minimize the amount of money they have to pay out in personal injury claims. One of the first places they’ll look to gather evidence is your social media accounts. Posts, photos, comments, and even “likes” can all be used to suggest that your injuries are not as severe as you claim, or to contradict statements made during the litigation process.

In Illinois, just like in many other states, there is no right to privacy on social media platforms. Anything you post publicly can be discovered and used as evidence in your case. Even posts that are set to “private” can potentially be obtained through legal means, such as subpoenas.

Here are several reasons why social media posts can negatively affect your car accident claim:

1. Contradicting Your Injury Claims

If you are pursuing compensation for injuries sustained in a car accident, such as back pain, whiplash, or a broken limb, any social media activity that appears to contradict your injury claims can be used against you. For example, if you post photos of yourself engaging in physical activities like hiking, attending parties, or traveling, the defense could argue that your injuries are not as severe as you claim, even if those activities were unrelated or took place before the accident.

Example:

• A Chicago woman who suffered a neck injury in a rear-end collision posted photos on Instagram from a weekend vacation where she appeared to be enjoying a hike. Even though the hike occurred before the accident, the defense used these photos to argue that she was physically capable of engaging in strenuous activities and was exaggerating the extent of her injuries. The case resulted in a significantly lower settlement than she anticipated.
  
  

2. Undermining Claims of Emotional Distress

Car accidents don’t just result in physical injuries; they often lead to emotional trauma, such as anxiety, depression, or post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Victims may seek compensation for emotional distress alongside physical injuries. However, if you post happy or carefree photos on social media, the defense may argue that you are not suffering from the emotional trauma you claim.

Example:

• A 34-year-old man from Naperville filed a personal injury claim after a car accident left him with chronic pain and severe emotional distress. He claimed that his injuries left him unable to enjoy life. However, shortly after the accident, he posted pictures from a friend’s wedding where he appeared to be laughing and having fun. These photos were used by the defense to cast doubt on the emotional toll the accident had taken on him. His emotional distress claim was significantly weakened as a result.
  
  

3. Admissions of Fault or Liability

After a car accident, it’s natural to want to share your experience online, perhaps to explain what happened or to express frustration. However, even a simple post explaining your side of the story can be twisted and used to suggest that you were at fault or partially responsible for the accident. Illinois operates under a modified comparative negligence system, which means that if you are found to be more than 50% at fault for the accident, you cannot recover compensation. Any admission of fault, even unintended, can severely impact your case.

Example:

• A driver involved in a car accident in Joliet posted on Facebook that they “didn’t see the other car coming” because they were checking their GPS. While the post was meant to explain the incident to friends and family, the defense used this as evidence to argue that the driver was distracted and, therefore, partially at fault. As a result, the compensation the driver received was significantly reduced due to Illinois’ comparative negligence laws.
  
  

4. Damaging the Credibility of Your Testimony

In a personal injury case, your credibility is key. The success of your claim relies heavily on whether the jury or the insurance company believes your account of the accident and the extent of your injuries. If your social media posts show behavior that contradicts your testimony, even if it’s unrelated to the accident, it could damage your credibility.

Example:

• A Springfield woman testified that her injuries from a car accident had left her unable to lift heavy objects or perform physical activities. However, she later posted photos on social media of herself lifting weights at the gym. Even though she was doing physical therapy as part of her rehabilitation, the defense argued that her social media posts showed she was not as injured as she claimed, resulting in a lower settlement offer.

Legal Implications of Social Media in Illinois Car Accident Claims

In Illinois, courts have ruled that social media posts are admissible as evidence in personal injury cases. This means that anything you post on social media can potentially be subpoenaed and used by the defense. Even if your social media accounts are set to private, Illinois courts may compel you to provide access to your accounts if the defense can demonstrate that your posts are relevant to the case.

Here are some key legal considerations in Illinois regarding social media use after a car accident:

1. Discovery Rules
Illinois courts allow broad discovery in civil cases, meaning that both parties can request access to a wide range of evidence that may be relevant to the case. This includes social media posts. If the defense believes that your social media activity contains information relevant to your injuries or the accident, they may request access to your accounts. Failing to comply with such requests can harm your case.

2. Privacy Settings Offer Little Protection

Many people believe that setting their social media accounts to “private” will protect them from having their posts used in court. However, Illinois courts have consistently ruled that privacy settings do not guarantee protection from discovery. If the court determines that your posts are relevant to the case, they can order you to provide access, even if your account is private.

3. Deleting Posts Can Backfire

After an accident, some people may be tempted to delete old posts that could be damaging to their claim. However, Illinois courts may consider the deletion of social media posts as “spoliation of evidence,” which means that you intentionally destroyed evidence relevant to the case. If the court finds that you deleted posts to hide evidence, it can result in severe penalties, including dismissal of your case or an adverse inference instruction to the jury.

What to Do (and Not Do) on Social Media After a Car Accident

If you’ve been involved in an auto accident in Illinois and are pursuing a personal injury claim, it’s essential to be cautious about your online activity, particularly on social media sites. Here are some tips to protect your claim:

1. Avoid Posting About the Accident

Do not post any details about the auto accident, your car accident injury, or how you are feeling after the crash. Even a seemingly harmless status update like “I’m okay” can be used to downplay your injuries or diminish the value of your insurance claim.

2. Avoid Posting Photos of Yourself

Refrain from posting photos of yourself, especially if they show you engaging in physical activities or having fun. These posts could be saved as screenshots and used to argue that your injuries are not as serious as you claim.

3. Set Your Accounts to Private

While privacy settings do not offer full protection, it’s still a good idea to set your social media accounts to private. This limits who can access your posts, including insurance adjusters who may send you friend requests of people you don’t know in an attempt to gather evidence.

4. Avoid Discussing Your Case

Do not discuss any aspects of your case online, including settlement negotiations, private messages about the accident, or conversations with your attorney. Keep all case-related matters private.

5. Consult with Your Attorney

Talk to your personal injury attorney or car accident lawyers about your social media use. They can provide guidance on what is and isn’t safe to post while your case is ongoing.

In Illinois, posting on social media after a car accident can have serious consequences for your personal injury claim. Insurance companies and defense attorneys often monitor online activity for evidence to question your injuries, credibility, and even your role in the accident. Accepting a new friend request from someone you don’t know could give them access to your status updates or private messages, creating unnecessary risks for your case.

By being mindful of what you post online and consulting with experienced car accident lawyers, you can avoid common social media pitfalls and protect your claim. In car accident cases, it’s always better to err on the side of caution and keep your personal life off social media sites until your case is resolved.

Working With Palermo Law Group

Navigating the aftermath of a car crash can be overwhelming, especially when you’re dealing with injuries and the stress of a potential personal injury lawsuit. At Palermo Law Group, our dedicated law firm is here to provide the legal advice and support you need to protect your rights. Whether you’re seeking justice for yourself or a loved one, our experienced team is ready to guide you through every step of the process.

We offer a free consultation to help you understand your options, answer your questions, and provide a thorough case evaluation tailored to your unique situation. If you or a family member has been impacted by a car crash, don’t face the challenges alone. Contact us today to start building a strong case and get the justice you deserve.

 

For a free consultation with Palermo Law Group, contact our law firm by calling (630) 684-2332 or visit our website at https://www.palermolawgroup.com/.